Answers

Why can't you reply to a Google review?

Usually the profile or the account is the reason, not the review. Google says you must verify the business before you can reply, and you need to be signed in to a Google Account that owns or manages the profile. A reply that does not appear may still be in Google's check, which usually takes up to 10 minutes and sometimes up to 30 days. A review Google removed for breaking its policies is not restored.

Check the account first

Google's page on managing reviews says: "Before you can reply to reviews, you must verify your business". Its verification page adds that to find your profile, you must sign in to the Google Account associated with it. So a missing Reply button often means the profile was never verified, or that you are signed in to a personal account rather than the one that manages the business.

Google's page on owners and managers says both roles can respond to reviews. If someone else holds the profile, such as a former employee or an agency, ask them to add you as an owner or to hand ownership back; the related answer on what to do if someone else controls your Google Business Profile covers that. The related answers on verifying a Google Business Profile and on giving someone access to it cover both steps.

Other reasons, side by side

What you seeGoogle's explanationWhat to do
Your reply does not appear yetReplies are checked first, usually within 10 minutes, sometimes up to 30 daysGive it time before writing a new one
Google asks you to edit your replyIt was not approved under Google's content policiesRemove what breaks the policy and post it again
The review has disappearedReviews can be delayed a few days while checked; ones removed for policy violations are not restoredSee the related answer on missing Google reviews
The review shows another website's nameProfiles may show reviews from other sites; Google says to contact that site about themReply on that site, if it allows replies
No reviews show on the profileReviews are offered only in certain countries, regions and business categories, and Google may pause them for some profilesCheck the profile's email for a notice from Google

When the profile itself has a problem

Google can also restrict a profile whose owner broke its fake engagement policy, for a set period and with an email first; a suspended profile is a separate case with its own appeal. The related answers on why Google reviews go missing and on why a Google Business Profile gets suspended cover both.

Once the Reply button works

What to write, especially to an unhappy customer, is covered in the related answer on responding to a negative Google review. As general advice, if the profile is verified, you are signed in as an owner or manager and the review is visible, yet there is still no way to reply, contact Google's Business Profile support rather than creating a second profile.

Sources

  1. Google Business Profile Help, "Manage customer reviews"
  2. Google Business Profile Help, "Verify your business on Google"
  3. Google Business Profile Help, "Manage your Business Profile owners & managers"
  4. Google Business Profile Help, "About missing or delayed reviews"
  5. Google Business Profile Help, "About third-party reviews"
  6. Google Business Profile Help, "Business Profile restrictions for policy violations"

Related answers

SEO for service businesses

Get found on Google by the people already looking for what you sell, in the places you serve, and see which searches turned into inquiries.